"Can You Make a Profit Just Backing Horses Over Your Own Price?"

Recorded August 2025 for The Grind Ep 4. Any figures mentioned are from that time.

There is a belief a lot of punters carry around, and it sounds sensible on the surface. Price every race, back anything that is longer than your price, lay anything that is shorter, and the profit takes care of itself. I do not think that holds up. Just because you mark a horse at a certain price, that does not make it a correct assessment of that horse's winning chance. Betting entirely on that basis is dangerous.

Pricing is decision making with incomplete information

When I price a race, I am making decisions in the face of incomplete information and general uncertainty. I am making a number of assumptions along the way. Some of those assumptions will be right, some will be completely wrong, and plenty will land somewhere in between. That is the nature of the work. It does not stop me doing it, but it should stop me treating the output as fact.

The part people miss is what happens when one assumption is off. If I have the wrong read on one horse in a race, it is not just that horse's price that is wrong. Every other price in that race is less correct as well, because a market has to add up. Push one horse too short and everything else is too long by default. So a single bad judgement does not sit quietly in one corner of the race. It leaks through the whole thing.

I went through a race in Adelaide and had one runner at five dollars. It was not an overlay on my own numbers. Fine. But that is one race, and one set of assumptions, and I have no way of knowing from the inside which of my assumptions were the shaky ones.

How the biggest syndicates handle it

The way around this is not to throw your own price out. It is to stop treating it as the only input. The biggest syndicates all do the same thing, and they have written about it openly. The Bill Benters of this world have put articles out on it. They factor in the public information as well. The Betfair odds, the bookie odds, the tote, the fluctuations, any bias they think sits in the market. All of that is information, and it comes from people who are also thinking hard about the race.

So they blend. Take the horse I had at five dollars. When I did the Saturday set on the Thursday, the market had it around ten. Rather than back my number and ignore theirs, they might weight the two prices fifty fifty and end up with the horse at seven dollars fifty. Do the same on the next runner. If the market has it at three twenty and I have it rated nine, the blend might land it around five fifty or six.

They work through the whole race like that, then convert the blended prices back to one hundred per cent. That rescaled set of prices is the market they bet into. Their own knowledge is in there, but so is everyone else's.

If you price races, keep doing it. Just stop assuming your number is the right one, and start asking how much weight it deserves against what the market is telling you.

Every race on the card, rated, with Kingsley's selections and the speed maps behind them. Your first day is free, no card needed.

More from Kingsley

• Why Betting Against Top Weights Pays in Group Races
• "What Should I Do When My Punting Gets Out of Control?"
• Why Is a Horse $2 When the Ratings Don't Support It?

From the full video: The Grind Ep 4 | Turning Ratings Into Profits – Real Betting Analysis & Mindset in Action

Gamble responsibly. 18+. If gambling is a problem for you, call Gambling Help on 1800 858 858 or visit gamblinghelponline.org.au